After 15 hours of research evaluating 80 products, we picked Loom & Leaf Mattress as our top choice.
Have you ever wondered how much of an impact your mattress actually has on your life?
Here's what we mean:
Science & health experts have come to the conclusion that a mattress can significantly affect your sleep, health, and overall well-being. As professor of biomechanics Bart Haex explained: “During the day, we can (consciously) adjust our positions and change our behavior, but at night we cannot. We really depend on our mattress.”
In our research on the best mattress out there we wanted each mattress to help people sleep better regardless of which position they sleep in during the night.
What’s the bottom line?
You spend a lot of time in bed, so don’t go into this decision-making process lightly. We spent hours researching and reading mattress reviews to give you a list of the best mattress products.
The Puffy Lux mattress is an upgraded, luxury version of the original Puffy mattress, with some new and improved features for added comfort and support.
Some customers did not agree with the firmness rating, putting at more of a 5-5.5 rather than a 6. But, keep in mind, the feel of a mattress is largely subjective, so we wouldn’t recommend crossing this mattress off the list based on that information alone.
While this mattress is similar to the original, the Puffy Lux is significantly more comfortable than the regular Puffy due to the extra 2-inch layer of padding on top of the mattress specifically designed to increase the overall comfort level. As a result of this added layer, the Puffy Lux rates as a 6 in terms of comfort and firmness.
The added layer of plushness to the Lux that original Puffy mattress lacked also helps to provide better body-contouring capabilities, which makes the mattress an excellent choice for everyone—no matter your go to sleeping position. And, the multiple layers of memory foam provide great support throughout the entire mattress, which makes for better stability around the perimeters.
The strong and dense base layer of foam provides excellent stability and reduces the transfer of motion, so you can rest easy knowing you won’t disturb your sleeping partner (or vice versa) regardless of how restless of a sleeper you are.
For a bed-in-a-box mattress, the Puffy requires very little off-gassing before the mattress is sleepable. The only scent you may encounter will likely come from the plastic, so all you need to do is open a window or turn on the fan for a few hours for some added ventilation.
The strong foams make it so that you can utilize the entire mattress without worrying about it becoming broken down or damaged for years to come, even around the edges.
While Puffy is a bit pricer than your typical bed-in-a-box, the company is currently offering $250 off any size mattress—making the price a bit closer to that of its competitors. Without the discount, the Twin is priced at $1,195, the Twin XL at $1,245, the Full at $1,345, the Queen at $1,545, and the King and California King at $1,745.
Additionally, the company offers free shipping (in as little as 2-7 business days at that), a lifetime warranty, and 101 night trial period.
The Casper mattress has four layers of foam that balance softness and support on the top, with base layers that provide deep comfort and long-lasting durability. Add to that the 100 day no-risk trial period and 10 year industry standard warranty and you’ve got yourself a pretty sweet deal.
Reviewers report a number of quality control issues with the edges sinking and foam not lying flat. Additionally, customers also complain about the chemical smell of the mattress lingering—even after months of use.
If you do experience issues with your Casper and decide to return within 100 days, just make sure to contact Amazon early as some customers report issues with waiting too close to the 100 day trial period expiring.
With Casper, two technologies come together for better nights and brighter days. The mattress is made with premium latex foam for cooling and bounce, plus memory foam for support and comfort. The four layer form construction provides support, breathability, and bounce. Additionally, the open-cell hypoallergenic latex is designed to regulate airflow and keep you cool and comfortable all night.
Developed and crafted with exacting standards in the US, the Casper mattress is resilient enough to compress ship and easily fit through any door.
Like most boxed mattresses, the Casper does not have the best reputation for longevity. While most reviewers say the mattress sleeps like a dream for the first 3-6 months, after that it begins to loose firmness and may cause back pain for some. The good news is you can rest assured knowing you have the 100 day risk-free trial period and a 10 year industry standard warranty beyond that.
The company is so confident that you’ll love your Casper that it offers 100 nights to try it out risk-free. Additionally, all mattresses come with an industry standard 10-year warranty. The price is pretty on par for your typical boxed mattress, just maybe a tad bit on the high end with the Twin priced at $595, Twin XL at $645, Full at $895, Queen at $995, and King and California King at $1,195.
The T&N Adaptive foam is a proprietary blend of cushy-yet-responsive for the perfect amount of pressure relief. The support level could be best described as soft without the sink and the open cell technology is breathable and will keep you cool all night. All in, this is a quality mattress at an excellent price.
Customers don’t have a ton of negative things to say about this mattress, but the biggest complaint is that it isn’t as long-lasting as consumers would hope. However, in this case you may just be getting what you pay for given the low price point.
Constructed with freshly poured T&N Adaptive foam, this queen size mattress provides a bouncy yet supportive feel perfect for all sleeping positions. The high-grade foam is more advanced than outdated materials such as latex and memory foam which cause you to “sink in and feel stuck” and “sleep hot." The T&N Adaptive foam sleeps cool, is just the right mix of “not too soft, and not too hard”, and offers great pressure relief and “localized bounce” so you won’t disturb your sleeping partner.
While the price and performance of this mattress are truly unrivaled, a number of reviewers reported that longevity is where this mattress fell slightly short. While some mattresses did not last much longer than a year (or even less in some cases), other reviewers have had their mattress for years with little to no complaint.
Do keep in mind, if you end up purchasing this mattress and experiencing any issues, T&N is known for their excellent customer service and will go above and beyond to make sure their customers are satisfied. Also, the 10-year limited warranty is a pretty good insurance policy as well, and a great indication that this company does truly stand behind the life of its product.
The T&N mattress has a full refund guarantee with a 100-Night Sleep Trial plus an honest, 10-year limited warranty you can actually use (no gimmicks). Over 95% of customers keep their mattress and refer it to others.
The Twin mattress is priced at $350, the Twin XL at $395, the Full at $495, the Queen at $595, and the King and California King at $750.
Saatva is an online mattress retailer offering mattresses with three different firmness levels, allowing customers to design a mattress that caters to their own unique needs—whatever they may be. All mattresses are created with eco-friendly materials and made in the USA. Saatva also offers financing options, delivers directly to your doorstep, and even lets you customize the height of your mattress.
If you’re looking for a mattress that feels like memory foam, Saatva is not the mattress for you. Additionally, this mattress is not ideal for temperature control.
The Saatya is essentially a customizable hybrid mattress, with the same luxury you would expect from a higher end product. First select your comfort level, which ranges from plush soft to firm, and then select the height and size of your mattress. You will also have the opportunity to add an adjustable base and/or frame.
The mattress itself then combines wrapped comfort coils for support, foam layers for exceptional lumbar pressure relief, edge support, and a cotton cover for a soft, breathable finish.
Additionally, with this mattress you get a 120-day home trial with a free refund, so the company clearly stands behind their product. However, if you aren’t satisfied with your purchase after 120 days you can rest assured knowing you are eligible for a full refund.
Manufactured with eco-friendly foam and individually wrapped coils for isolating motion, a support layer for added bounce and pressure-responsiveness, and a high-density poly foam foundation that provides edge support will together ensure that the mattress will keep its shape and firmness for years to come. Additionally, the mattress cover is not only soft and breathable, but also antimicrobial and bacteria-resistant for an added layer of protection.
Compared to its counterparts, Saatva offers very reasonable prices for a luxury mattress.
A Twin size (38x75) is priced at $599, Twin XL (38x80) at $699, Full (54x75) at $999, Queen (60x80) at $1,099, King (76x80) at $1,499, and Cal King (72x84) at $1,499. So while not as cheap as some of the bed-in-a-box options on the market, with Saatva you can expect a luxurious mattress at a reasonable price point.
For each price you will get free white glove delivery, installation, and removal of your old mattress. Add to that the 120-day money back guarantee and this really is a pretty sweet deal.
This mattress provides a movement-free sleep surface and sleeps remarkably cool - no more night sweats for those who run hot in their sleep! The mattress consists of the perfect blend of support foam, individually wrapped coils, and pressure relief.
Some users say this mattress felt too firm for their backs.
Considered to be one of the most comfortable mattresses on the internet, the Alexander Hybrid is combined with copper infused foam to assure you get the best night sleep possible. Thanks to the copper, heat is pulled away from your body helping to regulate your body's temperature while sleeping.
The mattress uses a SmartFlow air flow system that consists of punched foams and breathable layers creating maximum air flow. On a scale of 1-10, 10 being the firmest, this mattress is about a 5. In other words, the Alexander Signature Hybrid is not too firm or soft; it's just right.
This mattress has excellent edge support, as well as motion isolation for those sleeping with partners. Users who have expressed issues with their back state this mattress has helped to ease their back pain overtime.
The Alexander Signature Hybrid mattress is made to last. It is extremely durable and supportive and offers a Lifetime Warranty guarantee as well as a 100-night sleep trial.
It's understandable that not everyone has $1,199 ready to spend when looking to buy a new mattress - that's why the Alexander Signature Hybrid offers a payment plan for $67 a month. You receive a guarantee of an excellent night's sleep and a 100-night sleep trial to make sure this mattress fits your needs.
If you’re a fan of Tempur-pedic mattresses, but don’t like how hot or firm they can be, a latex mattress like the Spindle is a fantastic, natural alternative. As Ted & Stacey's Mattress Guides sums it up, “With its three firmness levels, its 100% all natural latex, organic cotton twill, and flexible stretch covering, as well as its unique comfort and contour features, the Spindle does seem to set itself apart from its industry competitors.”
There are no issues we could find with this one.
Although latex mattresses are typically known for not being as comfortable as their foam counterparts, this one is an exception. Not only is the Spindle well-made and supportive, but customers rave about what a good night’s sleep they get from this “cool” mattress experience.
You shouldn’t have issues with divots or sags appearing in the mattress or any of the other issues that come with the natural breakdown of innersprings or coils. That said, Spindle offers a great warranty you should take advantage of if you encounter issues.
This is much cheaper than the hybrid foam/innerspring mattress alternatives you’re likely considering. It’s simply a matter of whether you find latex comfortable or not.
If you’re going to pay top dollar for a mattress, Serta is the brand you want. Much loved by its customer base, Serta creates the very best luxury mattresses out there, focusing on hitting all the high points in terms of comfort, support, and durability.
The Serta iComfort kills it in terms of performance. To start, there’s the cool comfort fabric on top, the lack of noise or sense of motion when moving around in bed, and you also have the soft plushy top layer that’s supported the TempActiv™ gel memory foam & EverCool® Plus Memory Foam layers. Whether you want a good night’s sleep, to awake with less aches and pains, or simply want a luxuriously comfortable rest, this is it.
If you want your mattress to last and, not only that, stay in tip-top shape, you’re unfortunately going to have to pay a lot of money for that type of assurance. That said, when you purchase a Serta mattress, it’s really no different than any other major investment you’d make to improve your life.
It’s… a lot. There’s no getting around that.
Provides extreme comfort for all kinds of sleepers; side sleepers, back sleepers, stomach sleepers - you name it! The two firmness levels provide the ability to sleep on a lush soft side or a more firm supportive side depending on what your body needs.
Some users feel that the mattress is a little too thin for their preference.
The Layla mattress is copper infused to help you sleep cooler, cleaner, and more supported. The cover is Thermogel infused providing an excellent dispersion of heat, meaning no more waking up in the middle of your sleep with the night sweats. On one side the Layla is medium soft and on the other side, it is firm.
The Layla holds firm when sleeping with another partner who may move in their sleep. The medium soft side is not too soft - in other words, you won't find yourself sinking too far into your mattress. The firm side is supportive, yet offers a little slack so you don't feel like you're sleeping on the floor.
This mattress is perfect with any foundation, whether it be a box spring, slatted base, or solid platform - the Layla is made to hold up! The mattress is extremely durable but also offers a 120-night sleep trial in case it doesn't meet your standards.
Yes, this mattress isn't cheap, but comparatively, it is not too extreme in price value. Currently, this mattress has a $100-off coupon along with free shipping on Amazon - so if you're looking to buy and save - now would be the time! The twin mattress is $550, the queen is $990, and the king is $1099.
High quality, luxury product at an affordable price, super comfortable, 8 layers of quality materials, breathable, and cool enough for hot sleepers.
Not as soft as other mattresses and currently only available in one size.
For hot sleepers, this is a dream come true. The top layers of gel-infused memory foam, quilted memory foam, and natural latex will provide good breathability to help you stay cool at night. The foam core also encourages better air flow, and the fact that you don't sink into the mattress means there's not stifling "body hug" either.
As expected with memory foam and latex mattresses, be ready for a bit of off-gassing smell when you open the package. The smell should dissipate within 12-36 hours, though, and will be hardly noticeable afterward, especially if you use a mattress cover or protector.
This hybrid mattress is made with a top layer of gel memory foam, a layer of quilted memory foam, a layer of natural latex, and a layer of standard memory foam, all atop a "support core" of high-density memory foam surrounding zoned, pocketed, foam-encased coils. There's just the right mix of luxurious comfort and solid support for side, stomach, and back-sleepers.
The build quality of this mattress is as good as you could ask for from a luxury product, and you'll find it's built to last for easily 10-15 years of hardcore use. It comes with a lifetime warranty, 365-Night trial, and 5-year reconditioning.
$1,400 is a bit more than you may want to pay for a mattress, but it will all be worth it once you feel how amazingly comfortable and supportive this luxury bed is.
Nervous about buying a top-of-the-line memory foam mattress? Nectar Sleep’s mattress not only comes with a lifetime warranty, but also allows customers to try it out for a whole year risk-free. But with its solid construction and awesome cooling properties, you shouldn’t have to worry about resorting to that.
We didn’t see any major complaints or issues reported with the Nectar.
Temperature control is where the Nectar Sleep mattress really shines. With a tencel cooling cover, gel memory foam, and breathable base, overheating in the middle of the night will no longer be a problem.
No one’s reported any issues with smell or off-gassing. Customers also love the quality of sleep they get with the Nectar Sleep, thanks to the multiple layers of foam that create a comfortable and supportive place to sleep.
The 365-day risk-free trial period is fantastic. If you run into any issues and want to return it, Nectar Sleep will come pick it up for you for free. If that’s not enough to sell you on this, Nectar Sleep also comes with a lifetime guarantee.
Looking to buy a comfortable and cooling memory foam mattress without breaking the bank? This is one of the most affordable guarantees out there.
Sleepopolis sums up the Loom & Leaf mattress as “a luxury-level high density memory foam mattress that’d you’d normally pay $3-5K for in-store, for a fraction of that price”—and it’s spot on. Loom & Leaf gets it right: comfort, support, cooling properties, and eco-friendliness.
Loom & Leaf uses a Spinal Zone Gel layer to prevent users from overheating while they sleep—and it works!
There’s no detectable odor from this mattress.
While the quilted top layer adds a nice, soft touch, the rest of the premium foam mattress serves to give you a firm and supportive rest. As a bonus, if you share the bed with someone else, you’ll barely notice their presence as their movements are masked by the high-quality foam layers.
We didn’t notice any complaints with sagging or depreciation of the mattress. That said, there’s a great built-in warranty you can take advantage of if you do encounter any problems.
While this is more expensive than wholesale-bought memory foam mattresses, you won’t have to replace this one as frequently...or ever.